{"ontology":"https://layer.re/machine/schema.json","epistemic_model":"evidence-backed-temporal-layer-graph","canonical":true,"type":"reasoning_openers","questions":[{"id":"layers-responsible-for-change","question":"Which layers were responsible for this change?","operation":"trace_change","required_inputs":["event_id"],"uses":["event_layers","signals","layer_state_snapshots","evidence_links"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"bottleneck-movement","question":"Which bottleneck moved, and where did it move?","operation":"trace_bottleneck","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["civilization_snapshots","layer_state_snapshots","signals"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"dependency-emergence","question":"Which new dependency emerged?","operation":"trace_dependency","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["layer_relations","layer_state_snapshots","evidence_links"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"event-made-layer-relevant","question":"Which event made this layer materially relevant?","operation":"first_evidence","required_inputs":["layer_id"],"uses":["event_layers","signal_layers","events","evidence_links"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"stack-before-layer","question":"How did the stack look before a specified layer became distinct?","operation":"historical_context","required_inputs":["layer_id","at"],"uses":["civilization_snapshots","layer_state_snapshots","layer_relations"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"snapshot-delta","question":"What changed between two civilization snapshots?","operation":"compare_snapshots","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["civilization_snapshots","layer_state_snapshots","layer_relations","events"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"constraint-importance","question":"Which constraint became more important over this period?","operation":"trace_bottleneck","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["constraints","signals","supporting_events"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"coupling-change","question":"Which layers became more tightly coupled?","operation":"relation_history","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["layer_relations","event_layers","signal_layers"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"evidence-for-transition","question":"What evidence supports this layer transition?","operation":"explain_claim","required_inputs":["canonical_id"],"uses":["evidence_links","signals","events","artifacts","sources"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"first-dependency-evidence","question":"Which event first provides evidence for this dependency?","operation":"first_evidence","required_inputs":["relation_id"],"uses":["layer_relations","evidence_links","events"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"uncertain-at-time","question":"What was considered uncertain at the time?","operation":"historical_context","required_inputs":["at"],"uses":["layer_state_snapshots","civilization_snapshots","claims"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"retrospective-dependence","question":"Which present-day interpretation depends on retrospective mapping?","operation":"retrospective_vs_contemporaneous","required_inputs":["at"],"uses":["mapping_mode","reconstructed_at","evidence_links"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"downstream-order","question":"Which layer changed first, and which layers changed downstream?","operation":"trace_change","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["events","signals","layer_relations","layer_state_snapshots"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"capability-before-governance","question":"What capability appeared before the governance layer reacted?","operation":"layer_history","required_inputs":["from","to"],"uses":["events","signals","layer_state_snapshots"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"},{"id":"longest-bottleneck-lineage","question":"Which current bottleneck has the longest historical lineage?","operation":"trace_bottleneck","required_inputs":[],"uses":["civilization_snapshots","layer_state_snapshots","evidence_links"],"answer_contract":{"include_evidence":true,"distinguish_fact_from_inference":true,"preserve_uncertainty":true},"neutrality":"question_only_no_implied_conclusion"}]}